It is a strange measure of American priorities that some lawmakers have floated the idea of restricting Tylenol while guns remain practically a birthright.
Think about that.
A bottle of acetaminophen — something most of us reach for after a rough night’s sleep or a stubborn headache — now poses more legislative concern than weapons explicitly designed to kill. One can almost picture the irony: a country where you might have to think twice before buying medicine for the common cold, yet you can stroll into a store and walk out with an AR-15.
Yes, overdosing on Tylenol is dangerous. But so is walking into a school or grocery store in America where “active shooter drill” is now part of the national vocabulary. The logic feels upside down. We are told personal responsibility is sacred when it comes to firearms, yet somehow that principle evaporates when it comes to a pain reliever in nearly every medicine cabinet.
The truth is, banning or restricting Tylenol is a symbolic distraction. It makes politicians look like they are addressing safety while sidestepping the elephant in the room. Guns kill tens of thousands of Americans each year, and Tylenol helps tens of millions function. Whether or not it deserves more serious debate is not a difficult question. Pretending otherwise is not just nonsensical — it is an insult to common sense.
Only in America could politicians talk about banning Tylenol while treating guns like sacred objects. Wrap your head around that — a pill for headaches gets more scrutiny than a machine built for killing. It is the kind of logic that would be funny if it were not so pathetic.
Yes, Tylenol can be harmful in large doses, but so can water, caffeine or half the things in your kitchen. We do not see daily news about mass drownings at Starbucks; meanwhile, guns kill tens of thousands every year, turn classrooms into war zones and keep “active shooter drill” on every parent’s calendar. Yet somehow, the national conversation lands on pain relievers.
This is not about public safety. It is political theater. Lawmakers know guns are the issue, but touching that third rail risks campaign checks and angry lobbyists. Instead, they tilt at aspirin bottles and call it leadership. It is cowardice dressed up as concern.
Americans deserve better than this charade. Tylenol helps millions of people function through the day. Guns rip through families, neighborhoods and communities. If we cannot tell which deserves tighter control, then we have abandoned not just logic but basic decency.
Banning Tylenol while shrugging at gun violence is not just nonsensical. It is a dark reminder of how deeply broken our priorities really are.
The Slate welcomes thoughtful discussion on all of our stories, but please keep comments civil and on-topic. Read our full guidelines here.